Why 2025 Shapes Up to Be Roman Reigns’ Most Unpredictable Year Yet

For years, Roman Reigns’ path as WWE’s top star seemed preordained. Yet, as 2025 unfolds, a confluence of injury fallout, shifting creative plans, and his own evolving career is scripting what may be his most uncertain chapter yet

Reigns, a defining figure of WWE’s modern era, is navigating a landscape in flux. The long-term storylines that once anchored the company are being rewritten in real time, placing the “Tribal Chief” at the center of several potential, but unconfirmed, directions for 2025 and beyond

The Established Reign

Roman Reigns’ legacy is secure. After an impressive 1,316-day reign as Universal Champion, he is clearly one of the most dominant figures in WWE history. Even with a part-time schedule, his appearances are major events. Recently, he has begun focusing on projects outside the ring, including a role in an upcoming Street Fighter movie. This shift happens alongside a lighter wrestling schedule in 2025, making each of his matches more significant.

A Year of Altered Plans

The main reason for the current unpredictability comes from a significant creative change. Multiple wrestling news reports say that WWE’s initial plan for 2025 focused on a long-awaited match between Reigns and Seth Rollins. The story was already in motion, driven by Paul Heyman’s betrayal of Reigns to support Rollins.

However, this plan was reportedly canceled after Seth Rollins suffered a serious shoulder injury. He had to give up the World Heavyweight Championship, leaving WWE without one half of its planned main feud. This cancellation has left Reigns’ immediate future without a clear, defined opponent.

The Multiple Paths Forward

With the Rollins match off the table, speculation about Reigns’ 2025 future has branched in several directions, none yet official:

A WrestleMania Blockbuster: The focus is now on who Reigns will face at WrestleMania 42 in Las Vegas. He has hinted at targeting a world champion, leaving two top contenders: Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes or World Heavyweight Champion CM Punk. A third match with Rhodes would wrap up a notable trilogy, while a first major showdown with Punk provides an exciting, new option.

International Showdowns: Before any ‘Mania match, Reigns is expected to participate in major international events. Reports suggest a high-profile rematch with Australian powerhouse Bronson Reed is scheduled for WWE’s Crown Jewel event in Perth, Australia.

Long-Term Story Investments: Looking further ahead, there have been rumors, though unconfirmed, that Reigns himself suggested ideas to help develop new stars. One report indicated he was interested in a storyline where he would eventually lose a world title to the rising Bron Breakker in 2026.

Impact on the WWE Landscape

This uncertainty directly affects WWE’s entire story landscape. The main event for its biggest show of the year relies on Reigns’ chosen direction. Additionally, his infrequent schedule and star power create a void when he is not around. Industry veterans such as Mark Henry have noted that as part-time legends like John Cena step away, Reigns’ presence becomes even more important for supporting major events.

Analyst Perspective

From a neutral standpoint, 2025 marks an important change for Reigns. He is shifting from being the clear focal point of WWE to a unique role as a special attraction. His selective appearances can now define eras and lift others. The injury to Rollins was an unexpected setback, but it has created opportunities for several interesting stories. Analysts are asking if WWE will use Reigns to wrap up a past storyline with Rhodes or start a new one with Punk. Each choice will have different impacts on the roster.